FIRE—in the popular culture at least—used to come in one “flavor.” Imma call it vanilla.
To concoct it, start with a healthy dose of super-low living expenses, add a hearty dash of a huge saving and investing rate, and then mix in some measure of a messy middle waiting period.
Voila! Enjoy your resulting vanilla dessert: living off of 4% of your investments and/or other passive income, and/or real estate or other “passive” income and such. Think of it as vanilla ice cream.
Flavor profile
It’s yummy! But this one-flavor universe was never really so.
Some folks ultimately called this out, introducing into the lexicon different flavors, described as “barista FIRE,” “spouse wife FIRE,” “slow FIRE,” “coast FIRE,” and “fat FIRE. Also, “lean FIRE,” which really was just a rebranding of the O.G. vanilla.

Before I FIRE’d, I essentially wrote in this post that I’d likely be fortunate enough to enjoy a bowl of multiple scoops of ice cream. Vanilla, because we’d reached lean FIRE status. But also another flavor scoop, because I also benefitted from wife FIRE. We’ll call that flavor chocolate.
But when I actually FIREd, we’d in fact materially passed lean FIRE status, even if we were nowhere close to fat FIRE. I also was doing—and anticipated continuing to do—income-generating gig work. And I knew that I might also do some part-time and/or independent contractor income-generating work. And that The Missus and I would start receiving Social Security (state pensions) and a modest employer pension for The Missus well before the end of the traditional (for FIRE planning) 30-year retirement planning timeframe. And that we might receive one or more inheritances of unknown, but potentially material size. And that the odds favored us enjoying a favorable sequence of returns. And that if our situation went sideways, we were young, healthy, and resourceful enough to course correct to some degree or completely.
I think of these things as toppings. Whipped cream. Sprinkles. Hot fudge. Maraschino cherries. Chopped nuts. Marshmallow fluff. Crispies.
Of those potential toppings available to us to date (income-generating gig, contracting, and part-time work, and a favorable sequence of returns (barring 2022)), we’ve enjoyed all of them.
Had only a bowl of vanilla ice cream been on offer to me, I’d have enjoyed it. But the sundae we ended up with is tastier.
You (probly) have big bowls
Like I mentioned, the one-flavor-of-FIRE universe was never really so. I mean. I don’t know if anyone who’s FIREd ever just finished with and settled for a bowl consisting of a modest scoop of ice cream. I certainly don’t know anyone who has. And I’ve met hundreds of people who’ve FIREd.
Maybe folks don’t get enjoy a sundae like ours. But I think that almost all enjoy something more than a modest scoop of ice cream.
The rub, however, is that the base flavor ice cream scoop (assuming proper planning) is sufficient/tasty enough alone. Any additional other-flavored scoops and/or toppings could be stripped away. Probly no one wants that. But it need not mean no dessert.
It also means, I think, that many (most?) people are a lot more conservative than they could be. After all, if you know that other-flavored scoops and/or toppings are available to you, then FIREing with a mindset that you just have a single scoop of one flavor of ice cream necessarily doesn’t mirror objective reality.

Mind you, I’m not saying—much less advocating—that one should FIRE when they have a single scoop of ice cream or modest scoops of two flavors and/or a small amount of toppings. I mean, it’s possible that some of those extra flavors and/or toppings that one enjoys or believes he or she will enjoy get taken away. Or initially seem bigger than they end up being. Or only appeared to be there in the first place. This is why careful and realistic planning is critical. You don’t want any of those things to happen. Or at least you want to minimize the chances that they might. Better to be able to sleep at night than not.
Even as a natural pessimist, however, I think it’s helpful to be optimistic. Because the likelihood that you’re just going to end up with a plain bowl of vanilla (or other single-flavor) ice cream is just such a remote possibility as to be almost wholly unrealistic. Don’t be unrealistically optimistic, but, also, don’t be unrealistically pessimistic.
To bring it back to our situation, I knew we had a pretty robust sundae when I FIREd. A scoop of vanilla ice cream. A scoop of chocolate. Whipped cream. Sprinkles. Hot fudge. Maraschino cherries. Chopped nuts. Marshmallow fluff. Crispies. But I behaved and planned as if we had something lesser. Say, a sundae with maybe a small scoop of vanilla, a small scoop of chocolate, and far fewer toppings.
I’m glad that I had that mindset. Over time, my reality matched my sundae-focused predictions. Exceeded them in fact. On the flip side, however, that means I probly could’ve FIREd earlier.
And in the end . . .
I don’t have any regrests, but I sometimes ponder whether I was too conservative? Probly Maybe I was. But was my dessert at the point that I FIREd the right amount of tasty? Darn tootin’ it was. And nothing like that modest bowl of vanilla ice cream. Which wouldn’t have been the worst thing in the first place.
